horror and science fiction DVD and movie reviews and previews from curledupdvd.com - curled up with a good dvd
horror and sci-fi DVD reviews and previews from curledupdvd.com - curled up with a good dvd
DVD reviews, previews and info - horror and science fiction
  action movies on DVD
  animation on DVD
  art house and international / foreign language films on DVD
  comedies on DVD
  documentaries on DVD
  dramas on DVD
  children's and family DVDs
  horror and sci-fi on DVD
  suspense on DVD
  television series on DVD
  Blu-ray DVD reviews


The Day the Earth Stood Still (3-Disc Special Edition - 2008) - science fiction DVD / action adventure DVD / remake DVD review
Rated PG-13 by the Motion Picture Association of America curledupdvd.com rating: 2 stars
Actors: Keanu Reeves, Jennifer Connelly, Kathy Bates, John Cleese, Jaden Smith
Director: Scott Derrickson   Distributor: 20th Century Fox
DVD release: 07 April 2009   Runtime: 104 minutes (3 discs)
Format: Black & White, Full Screen, Special Edition
DVD features: Aspect ratio 2.35:1, Audio tracks (Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround - English; Dolby Digital Stereo - English, Spanish, French), Subtitles (English, Spanish, French), Packaged with the original 1951 version of the film, Deleted scenes, Re-Imagining The Day, Unleashing Gort, Watching The Skies: In Search Of Extraterrestrial Life, The Day The Earth Was "Green", Commentary (writer David Scarpa), Still galleries, The Day The Earth Stood Still digital copy

What a frustrating disappointment.

That was my first thought as soon as this movie ended. There is so much to like about this film that it is indeed frustrating when the wheels somewhat come off the tracks near the end. The movie is still worth seeing (at least as a rental), but some poor choices in the plot plus a fatal turn toward "hokiness" keep The Day the Earth Stood Still from being all it could have been.

The story (which, for those unaware, is a remake of an early 1950's sci-fi classic): an alien space-sphere lands in Central Park. A team of scientists is rounded up quickly, including astrophysicist Dr. Helen Benson (Jennifer Connelly) and taken to the location. While there, an alien with "elephant-like skin" is accidentally shot by a panicked soldier. The wounded alien is followed off the spaceship by Gort, a fearsome, faceless robotic creature at least 30 feet tall. The wounded alien stops Gort from destroying the soldiers before he is taken to an underground bunker for treatment.

While in the bunker, an operating surgeon discovers that, astonishingly, the elephant-like skin is actually an advanced form of organic spacesuit for a humanoid creature. The wounded alien, now known as Klaatu (Keanu Reeves) is taken in for interrogation. Without giving it away, he easily overpowers his questioner and takes first the man's key card, then his clothes. In an awesome shot, a rather imposing Klaatu marches methodically through a hallway lined with security guards who are powerless to stop him and heads to the elevator to make his escape.

Again, the movie looks like it's going to be terrific. However, when Klaatu, is "rescued" later by Dr. Benson and her stepson, Jacob (Jaden Smith), the film loses all the momentum it had at the start and never fully recovers. For one thing, the film becomes the now-clichéd plot point of the fate of the world coming down to three people (conveniently, a man, woman and child). Second, to be blunt, Jacob is a whiny brat who does not garner sympathy. Indeed, a selfish act by Jacob at the midpoint of the story nearly guarantees Armageddon and costs some lives -Jacob deserves a much more severe reprimand than he gets here. Finally, the moment which causes a change of heart on the part of Klaatu (one major change from the original: this current version of Klaatu has not been sent to Earth to warn it about impending Armageddon, but to enforce it) is not as moving as it should be but instead comes across as cheesy and forced.

Not all is bad about the ending, however, particularly the true nature of Gort's purpose. It turns out that the robot is the ultimate weapon of mass destruction. How it is a weapon I will not reveal, but it is truly innovative and frightening.

Again, the film is worth a look - it has very good special effects and a great opening. If only it hadn't turned sappy (and had dropped the obnoxious kid character), it could have been truly special.

Note: Some other reviews have made references to Klaatu as a Christ figure. I personally did not see anything overt. What Biblical allusions there are tie in much more with Noah's Ark (and, to a lesser extent, the Exodus) than they do to the New Testament.

  • Deleted scenes
  • Commentary by writer David Scarpa
  • Reimagining the Day (making-of feature)
  • Unleashing Gort (an interesting feature focusing on Gort; better than the making-of feature)
  • Watching the Skies: In Search of Extraterrestrial Life (the best extra; an engaging discussion with scientists and professors on the search for life in the universe)
  • The Day the Earth Was Green (a rather bland feature on the efforts Fox made to film the movie in an environmentally friendly way)
  buy this DVD now or browse millions of other great products at amazon.com
reviewed by Trent Daniel
    action | animation | art house/international | comedy | documentary | drama | family | horror/sci-fi | suspense | television    
    browse DVDs alphabetical by title    
    contact | home